《网站重构：应用Web标准进行设计》的书评

这本书我要说的是：太会包装了，从名字到设计。
原书的标题是：Designing with Web Standards，内容就是于web设计相关的一些启蒙或故事，我个人感觉就是本“科普”类的书。但出版商很厉害，知道“重构”这个词最近很热，很吸引人，把这个当成了主标题，原书名成了副标题。我把这本书看了2/3，可以很负责的说，这个书和我们之前见到的“重构”没有任何关系。
另外这本书包装印刷精美，封面封底前言n多溢美之词，装帧设计也很有国外影音版的风格。但我只能说，金玉其表...

如果你想找本关于web设计的消遣读物，本书很适合你。

发表评论

我赞同(0人)

我反对(3人)

回复评论展开>

2007-1-9 11:00:43 读者 : flasherfffff - 【翻译】重要但是有缺陷的书

【原文】
Make no mistake. This is an important book. Zeldman is a leader in the web standards movement and his voice is worth paying attention to. On the plus side, he offers some good talking points for using with bosses and clients on why designing with web standards is a good thing. He also gives reasonable and well thought out examples and case studies of well designed sites.

On the other hand, the complaints about his rambling, preaching and repetition are valid. The book lacks tight focus, trying to be a polemic, a high level overview and a how-to manual.

This is a book that is worth reading or at least skimming. If you are one of the converted and want to feel good about your choices, this will give you warm fuzzies. If you need convincing on the whether or not web standards are worth the effort to implement, this offers a strong and cogent argument for doing so. Im not sure that is is worth buying as a reference manual. There are more focused how-to books and more complete reference books.
【翻译】
不要搞错了。这本书确实是很重要的。Zeldman 是网页标准运动的领导者，他的话语值得关注。一方面，他提供了几点老板和客户都可以用的

内容，关于为什么要按标准设计网页。而且他也给出了一些很好的想法和例子，这些都是出自设计良好

的网站。
另一方面，对这本书的散漫、随意和不断重复确实存在着抱怨。本书试图成为一本讨论性的、高层次上总览全局的、教给人们怎么去做的书，但缺少严谨的主题。
这本书值得阅读，至少是浏览一下。如果你在开发中想参考本书以，那么你会感到迷惑。如果你想确信网页标准是必要的，那么这本书会提供足够的论据和内容。作为一本开发时的参考书，我不确定是否值得买它。因为有很多其他的书叫你如何做网页，或者更适合做参考书。

发表评论

我赞同(0人)

我反对(0人)

回复评论

2007-1-1 15:59:14 读者 : iaags - 【翻译】Designing with Web Standards

【原书评内容】
Lots of knowledge, somewhat redundant, September 26, 2006
Reviewer: Matthew Keefe 'mkeefe' (Boston, MA USA) - See all my reviews
I got this book a while back and did learn a lot from it, which some of the tips and techniques I still use today. However I did find the book to be very redundant in some of the explanations and techniques. I did however like the fact that real world examples where given and there was no browser favoring from the author which is really good considering a book isnt suppose to be an ad like so many other authors seem to think.
This has easily become a top 5 in my arsenal of CSS knowledge that I have passed down to my friends and acquaintances.
I must say though, if you are looking for a quick '101 tips' book than this isnt for you. It does have a lot of theory and history as well.
【翻译内容】
知识内容非常多，不过有些内容没什么用
2006年9月26日
评论者:Matthew Keefe 'mkeefe'(Boston,MA USA)
我得到这本书有一阵子了，从这本书上学到很多东西，这上面的很多提示和技术我一直使用到今天。但是我发现这本书在有些方面写得过滥。不过我更喜欢有实例的书，许多作者认为那些不准备把书写得像广告一样一看就明白的作者对读者没有帮助。
这本书成了我收藏的5本最好的CSS方面的书之一。我也传给我的朋友和熟人一起分享。
但是我必需说的是，如果你需要的是一本能快速指引你使用CSS的书的话，这本书不适合你。因为这本书大部分是讲理论和CSS历史的。
【译者】iaags (水平有限，错误之处请指教)

发表评论

我赞同(0人)

我反对(0人)

回复评论

2006-12-29 16:30:50 读者 : 60.14.147.* - 头一次CSDN推荐的书我在图书馆找到